Tuesday, 13 September 2022 11:55

Better than the ETS!

Written by  David Anderson
BLNZ chair Andrew Morrison concedes that the HWEN proposal is "not perfect". BLNZ chair Andrew Morrison concedes that the HWEN proposal is "not perfect".

Beef+Lamb New Zealand chair Andrew Morrison says his organisation understands farmers' concerns about the He Waka Eke Noa (HWEN) recommended option.

"This is a complex issue with significant implications and it's really important that we listen and talk with all our farmers and ensure they fully understand what's proposed," he told Rural News.

"Like farmers, we would prefer there was no pricing of agricultural emissions. However, the Government has already passed a law that means emissions will be priced through the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) if we don't make progress on HWEN."

Morrison says the groups behind HWEN fought to have an opportunity to develop an alternative pricing mechanism to the ETS and convinced the Government in 2019 to work on an alternative.

"At that time, the Government had legislation written to bring us into the ETS in 2020," he explains;. "The ETS would be far worse for our farmers. We would lose the split gas methane target; effectively facing a net zero target for methane, and the methane price would be linked to the soaring carbon price."

Morrison says under the ETS farmers also wouldn't have access to the additional sequestration in the HWEN proposal or payments to farmers for using technologies that reduce their emission like low methane sheep. "While they (the HWEN proposals) still need work, the split gas methane targets were a win for agriculture in 2019 because around 19,000 consultation submissions had supported all gases going to net zero."

He concedes that the HWEN proposal is "not perfect". However, Morrison says with agriculture remaining outside the ETS, it will have the opportunity to refine HWEN over time as new science, technologies and mitigation tools become available.

"We are really conscious of the potential financial impact on farmers. This is a fundamental reason we have fought to stay out of the ETS," he told Rural News.

Morrison says the HWEN partners have tried to manage the financial impacts within HWEN, including through the price setting principles, which are supposed to take account of economic impacts and emissions leakage.

"We also pushed for a recommended maximum starting rate for methane of 11c per kilo to be held for the first three years and a specific levy relief provision," he adds. "For farmers that do not have sequestration or access to effective mitigation technologies, there is a specific proposal for providing levy relief on a case-by-case basis."

Morrison says sequestration is a deal-breaker.

"While we are conscious some farmers, especially in the South Island, don't have access to this, if that were to be carved off, this would fundamentally change HWEN, and we'd need to reconsider our involvement."

Morrison admits the agriculture sector didn't get everything it wanted.

"However, HWEN recognises a wider range of vegetation than the ETS. It also recognises native vegetation that is ineligible under the ETS," he claims. "Our long-term goal is to get the ETS improved to include this vegetation, but the reality is this will take years."

Morrison says if farmers are to face a price for their emissions, it's a bottom line they have to be able to get proper recognition for their sequestration from that day.

"That's why we are pushing for it to be HWEN for now."

He says outside of HWEN, BLNZ have been urging the Government to review the "unfairly high" methane reduction targets in legislation, currently a 10% reduction by 2030 and a reduction of between 24-47% by 2050.

"The target for carbon dioxide is to get to net zero (or no additional warming) by 2050. Based on the latest science, an equivalent target for methane to contribute no additional warming would be a 10% reduction by 2050," Morrison adds.

"We're also urging the Government to report on warming as well as emissions and to ensure the legislated review of these targets in 2024 uses the latest science - that means using appropriate metrics such as GWP*."

He says BLNZ is working across the agriculture sector with dairy, deer and arable on this.

More like this

Lost the room?

OPINION: Beef+Lamb NZ has run a roadshow to sell its new strategy.

Positive signs, says McClay

First up to the podium at the recent Tractor and Machinery Association (TAMA) Conference in Wellington, Minster for Agriculture, Todd McClay, reflected on a difficult 12 months, but hinted at signs that things were turning the corner, saying “when ag does well, New Zealand does well”.

Featured

Massey Research Field Day attracts huge interest

More than 200 people turned out on Thursday, November 21 to see what progress has been made on one of NZ's biggest and most comprehensive agriculture research programmes on regenerative agriculture.

Expo set to wow again

Stellar speakers, top-notch trade sites, innovation, technology and connections are all on offer at the 2025 East Coast Farming Expo being once again hosted in Wairoa in February.

A year of global challenges

As a guest of the Italian Trade Association, Rural News Group Machinery Editor Mark Daniel took the opportunity to make an early November dash to Bologna to the 46th EIMA exhibition.

National

Winter grazing warning

Every time people from overseas see photographs of cows up to their hocks in mud it's bad for New Zealand.

ANZ defends farm lending rates

The country's largest lender to the agriculture sector says it's not favouring home loans over farm and business lending.

Machinery & Products

Expo set to wow again

Stellar speakers, top-notch trade sites, innovation, technology and connections are all on offer at the 2025 East Coast Farming Expo…

A year of global challenges

As a guest of the Italian Trade Association, Rural News Group Machinery Editor Mark Daniel took the opportunity to make…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Review SOEs!

OPINION: NIWA has long weathered complaints about alleged stifling of competition in forecasting, and more recently, claims of lack of…

Bank reset

OPINION: Adding to calls to get banks to 'back off', NZ Agri Brokers director Andrew Laming has revealed that the…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter