Tuesday, 27 June 2023 12:55

LIC questions single breeding index proposal from DairyNZ

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
LIC chief executive David Chin says the co-op’s investment in genomics is delivering significant value to LIC farmers. LIC chief executive David Chin says the co-op’s investment in genomics is delivering significant value to LIC farmers.

Farmer co-operative LIC says changes to the current animal evaluation model proposed by DairyNZ isn’t the way forward.

In a submission to DairyNZ last week, LIC says it welcomes increased competition around herd improvement.

“We understand some farmers might want a simpler animal evaluation system with a single index and we will continue to work with DairyNZ to find a solution for that – but their proposal is not the way forward.

“We strongly believe that the co-operative is in a strong position to deliver for you under the current model, and we will continue to put our heads down to focus on our core mission to support herd improvement in New Zealand.”

In a letter to farmer shareholders, LIC chief executive David Chin says the co-op, representing over 9000 dairy farmers, has invested heavily in genomics on their behalf.

China says this is delivering significant value to LIC farmers.

“Genomic bulls are widely available for AB and the majority of our 9000+ farmers are utilising them,” says Chin.

DairyNZ - through subsidiary New Zealand Animal Evaluation Ltd (NZAEL) - believes that creating one animal evaluation index would ensure breeding decisions are made consistently.

It proposes that a single evaluation will be co-ordinated by NZAEL, as an industry good, credible source of data available to everyone to use.

The sector is currently using three Breeding Worth animal evaluation indexes – owned respectively by LIC, CRV and NZAEL. DairyNZ chair Jim van der Poel says this creates confusion in the sector – and sub-optimal outcomes.

However, in his letter, Chin says it’s not clear who the proposal really benefits.

“While the proposal aims to facilitate more competition in the AB market, we note that competition in the AB market exists today in New Zealand, with opportunities already available for new players to enter the market. This is to the benefit of New Zealand farmers, and the existing competition helps to drive investment in R&D.

“The proposal would risk disincentivising investment in R&D without clear benefits for increasing the choice of AB providers for farmers.”

Chin claims the proposal will increase costs to farmers and the industry.

“While the proposal is intended to make genomics more widely available for New Zealand farmers, most farmers in New Zealand have ample access through LIC and are receiving value on farm. DairyNZ is proposing to use farmer-levy money to re-create a genotype database which already exists.

“The proposal also contains an unclear and confusing fee model, with a lack of clarity on how exactly the model would be funded. For example, there is reference to straw levies and levies for cow enrolment via herd record providers as optional charges depending on what other fees are included.

“Although it is unclear how DairyNZ intends to enforce collection of these levies, ultimately all costs are borne by the industry one way or another.”

Chin also questions how the proposed single breeding index would operate without the participation of LIC and other existing AB companies.

The proposal requires all parties to be involved, including LIC.

But Chin says the current model does not encourage participation by current industry participants.

“The proposal fails to address how the model would operate and how it would be funded should existing companies, including LIC, choose not to participate.”

LIC also claims the ‘size of the prize’ is based off flawed assumptions and is not accurate.

It is not clear what the problem is that DairyNZ is trying to solve, says Chin.

“The proposal claims that there is an opportunity of $1.36 billion return on farm over the next 10 years by increasing BW year-on-year through genomics. There is no independent modelling or evidence to support this opportunity. In fact, the modelling associated with the proposal is retrospective and only looks at data up to 2020.”

Submissions on DairyNZ’s proposal close this week.

More like this

Musical chairs

OPINION: DairyNZ's director elections has seen scientist Jacqueline Rowarth re-elected for another three-year term.

DairyNZ levy to increase?

Retiring chair Jim van der Poel has used his final AGM to announce the intention to increase the DairyNZ farmer levy for the first time in the industry-good body's 17-year history.

Tributes to retiring 'Jim the farmer'

Doing what is right, not what is easy, has been the hallmark of Jim van der Poel's leadership of, and advocacy for, the dairy industry, attendees at the DairyNZ annual general meeting heard last week.

Featured

New ag degrees at Massey

Changing skill demands and new job opportunities in the primary sector have prompted Massey University to create a new degree course and add a significant major into another in 2025.

The show is on!

It was bringing in a new Canterbury A&P Association (CAPA) show board, more in tune with the CAPA general committee, that has ensured that Christchurch will have a show this year, says CAPA general committee president Bryce Murray.

National

'Quite a journey'

Former Synlait chief executive Grant Watson says the past two years have been quite the journey.

DairyNZ levy to increase?

Retiring chair Jim van der Poel has used his final AGM to announce the intention to increase the DairyNZ farmer…

Former Fonterra CEO dies

Former Fonterra chief executive Theo Spierings passed away in the Netherlands over the weekend.

Machinery & Products

Milk Sustainability Centre launched

The recently announced Milk Sustainability Centre – a collaboration between global giant John Deere and milking and feed specialists De…

Data connection made easier

New Holland and Case IH are introducing new advancements in their precision technology stack to make farming easier and more…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Feed from farmers

OPINION: The country's dairy farmers will now also have a hand in providing free lunch for schools.

Brighter future

OPINION: The abrupt departure of Synlait chief executive Grant Watson could be a sign that Chinese company Bright Dairy, the…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter