Thursday, 05 December 2024 10:55

Testimonials aren't science research

Written by  Jacqueline Rowarth
Dr Jacqueline Rowarth Dr Jacqueline Rowarth

OPINION: Personal recommendations often appearing as testimonials, are not the same thing as scientific research.

Most people know this, yet the testimonials keep appearing. Celebrities are finding themselves in hot water (Elle McPherson’s holistic treatment leading to remission from what is now known was stage 0 cancer is a case in point). Professionals are trying to promote actual research rather than testimonials. And in agriculture we are constantly being told we should look to new solutions that are backed by, you guessed it, testimonials.

Testimonials can sometimes be validated through research, but the importance of the crystal effect must never be forgotten. David Swain, agricultural science editor for decades, explained to the uninitiated that a crystal placed in the centre of a farm, and turned through 90 degrees daily, would increase farm productivity. The key was to approach the crystal from a different direction and leave in another direction, every day. And on the way the farmer noticed that the ewes needed drenching, the fence needed mending, the calves needed moving, the pasture needed topping…

The crystal gave renewed interest which in turn increased productivity.

Human response is key and is one of the factors that scientific research tries to eliminate when identifying drivers of change. Other factors are removing the effect of field variability using replication and controls, and repeating the research in different seasons, years and, possibly, location – all in an effort to be sure that the outcome is due to a driver, not chance.

Nitrogen (N) use is one of the changes being regulated in agriculture. Farmers trying to stay solvent are being urged to cut use of nitrogen fertiliser and many companies are trying to assist. Ravensdown and Ballance have produced a range of options with the overall mantra of Right Product, Right Amount, Right Place and Right Time. Other companies have produced proprietary formulations which appear to be effective in some circumstances.

Dr Rachael Bryant, Associate Professor in Lincoln University’s Department of Agricultural Sciences, specialises in pasture agronomy, including the impact of technologies. Much of her research involves finding commercial tools to solve practical problems. She works with farmers and industry professionals, testing ideas and then explaining the outcomes. Some of her latest research, funded by MPI, was presented at the NZ Grassland Association Conference held in Oamaru at the beginning of November. Her paper (with co-authors Greig and Mangwe) is freely available on the Grassland.org.nz website.

The plot trial research examined whether tactical use of N fertiliser, applied with or without coating or biostimulant, improved herbage yield and N use efficiency. Results indicated that when applied at the same rate, but different timings, combining urea with a coating or biostimulant altered the distribution of pasture growth, but did not affect net annual production or herbage quality. The greater application costs associated with liquid versus granular products meant that the new products achieved the same response as urea but with greater expense.

This was at the Lincoln test site, which Dr Bryant is quick to acknowledge is a relatively high fertility site, but nitrogen response was shown by the difference in yield between zero N addition and the N treatments.

The outcome was not new but did use currently available products.

Dr Doug Edmeades, soil scientist and managing director of agKnowledge, has explained the science behind products repeatedly. His explanations can be found on the agKnowledge website (agknowledge.co.nz) in Fertiliser Review. Chemical versus biological fertiliser is one of the tabs linking to seven informative articles. Another tab is the Base Saturation Ratio Theory (Kinsey-Albrecht) with six articles explaining the two different approaches and why, for New Zealand, sticking with the MPI (MAF and various predecessors) approach is more likely to achieve least cost responses. This is because it focuses on overcoming limitations to production by applying necessary nutrients.

Agricultural research started in New Zealand over 100 years ago and has developed an approach that is appropriate for the soils and environment, as well as different farming systems. That approach involves pasture species as well as nutrients, and has been tried, tested and documented for decades. The first reports of the NZ Grassland Association conferences were published in the 1930s, and some of the fundamental principles of management have not changed.

Nor has the desire for scientists, farmers and rural professionals to work together to identify ‘a better way’.

Testimonials can be a very good start to an investigation. The questions on ‘why was the change made and how appropriate are the circumstances to my operation?’ might assist the next steps. But it is scientific research that will examine the drivers of change and be able to identify what made the difference.

Dr Jacqueline Rowarth, Adjunct Professor Lincoln University, has an honours degree in Environmental agriculture, a PhD in Soil Science and is on the board of directors of DairyNZ, Deer Industry NZ and Ravensdown.

More like this

Ag sector is here to stay

OPINION: In twelve months’ time, plus or minus, we’ll be in the same place, give or take, and thinking the same things, more or less.

Faulty models used to measure emissions

OPINION: If you have kept your finger on the emissions pulse, none of the below information will be a surprise to you. However, if you are a farmer that has not been following New Zealand’s ruminant methane issue then you may be in for a nasty shock.

Featured

Major shakeup for the NZ science system

The government has announced a major restructuring of the country's seven crown research institutes (CRIs), which will see them merged into three public research organisations (PROs).

Putting theory into practice

Hamish and Rachel Hammond jumped at the chance to put their university learning into practice by taking up a contract milking offer right after graduation.

Workers a big part of the farming business

"We couldn't do this without our team. They are integral to everything." That's the first thing that Te Awamutu dairy farmers Jayson and Stacey Thompson have to say about their team.

Editorial: O Canada

OPINION: The Canadian government's love affair with its lifestyle dairy farmers has got it into trouble once again.

Tough year for UK farmers

Volatile input costs, fluctuating commodity prices, a reduction in direct payments and one of the wettest periods in decades that resulted in a disastrous harvest, have left their mark and many UK farming businesses worse off.

National

New insights into rural fire risk

New student research from the University of Canterbury in partnership with Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) could improve knowledge…

Embrace mechanical weeding now

Mechanical weeding is exploding in Europe because increasing resistance means they have "run out of herbicide", says Canterbury agronomist Charles…

China still a good option

The ongoing rise of the Chinese middle class will drag up demand for New Zealand products there in the future.

UAE FTA signed

New Zealand’s free trade deal with the United Arab Emirates (UAE) has now been signed.

Machinery & Products

Batten Buddy - cleverly simple

Stopping livestock from escaping their environment is a “must do” for any farmers or landowners and at times can seem…

U10 Pro Highland a step up

A few weeks after driving the CF MOTO U10 Pro ‘entry level’ model, we’ve had a chance to test the…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Drunk on power!

OPINION: The end-of-year booze-up at the posh Northern Club in Auckland must have been a beauty, as the legal 'elite'…

Time has come?

OPINION: It divides opinion, but the House has passed the first reading of the Gene Technology Bill.

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter