Wednesday, 17 June 2020 10:07

Reality bites — Editorial

Written by  Staff Reporters

OPINION: Hopes for any quick outcome of free trade talks with the European Union have hit the wall following a “paltry” market access offer for our agriculture sector.

The decision by the European Union to offer NZ farmers an FTA deal that is even worse than the status quo is nothing short of a gratuitous insult. To have leaked it to some mates, before even telling our government, compounds the situation and is a careless and shoddy act of diplomacy unbecoming of a modern democracy. 

NZ has every right to be angry and to question the honesty of the EU Commission, which has long claimed it was in favour of a comprehensive, ambitious and very special trade deal with us. 

EU Trade Commissioner Phil Hogan, who was in NZ 18 months ago, said that “there a great deal of goodwill around the FTA negotiating table” and the EU “were very strong supporters of the multilateral trading system”. 

When officially launching the talks two years ago, his predecessor Cecilia Malstrom said the EU was “opening up a new chapter of economic possibilities for companies and giving choices to consumers as well also deepening the strategic ties” and that “NZ is a friend and an ally and it, along with the EU, stood up for common values as expressed in sustainable trade and done in compliance with international trade rules”.

It sounded great at the time and NZ was made to feel that a good deal was on the cards, but on reflection you might ask, was this just political bull or a bunch of lies? What has changed and why can’t the EU deliver on its promises? 

Phil Hogan has a lot to answer for.  Will he put things right and give us a fair FTA or will he take on the mantle of European arrogance and go down the road of protectionism and make the world an even worse place? 

Will he have the guts to rise above entrenched the petty protectionists of the EU and take a long-term strategic stance and allow the EU and the world to trade itself out of the Covid-19 crisis? Don’t hold your breath. 

The quality of a market access offer for the agriculture sector to the EU has long been seen as a stumbling block for a conclusion to talks. Trade Minister David Parker says a strong agriculture access offer was a red line for NZ negotiators and NZ could not afford for the status quo to continue.

It looks like Parker and NZ’s trade negotiators have a long row to hoe to get the EU over the line.

More like this

EU regulations unfairly threaten $200m exports

A European Union regulation ensuring that the products its citizens consume do not contribute to deforestation or forest degradation worldwide threatens $200m of New Zealand beef and leather exports.

EU/NZ FTA signed soon?

The European Union's ambassador to NZ, Nina Obermaier, is hopeful that the FTA negotiated last year will be signed off by the middle of this year.

Sweet deal for EU honey exports

The impact of a new European Union free trade agreement removing a 17.3% tariff on NZ-sourced honey in July is translating into increasing sales volumes, according to one exporter.

Featured

Pāmu Opens Farm Gates for Summer Open Farm Days

State farmer Pāmu is opening its farm gates this summer in an effort to give the rural sector the opportunity to see how large-scale, multi-system farming is delivering productivity and profitability across New Zealand.

DairyNZ: Waikato Farmers Need Certainty on PC1 Rules

DairyNZ says Waikato farmers need certainty on Plan Change 1, but they say that certainty must be matched with practical, workable rules and a clear transition that doesn't get ahead of the new resource management system currently under review.

National

Machinery & Products

 

 

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Great Idea!

OPINION: Central Hawke's Bay farmer Mark Warren recently told the Hawke's Bay Times it's time for a conversation about allowing…

No Choice

OPINION: A nation that relies as heavily as NZ does on functional global shipping lanes will have to do its…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter