Wednesday, 02 March 2016 07:55

Public expectations on water need to be realistic

Written by 
Nick Smith. Nick Smith.

Understanding water issues are complex, but many people do not appreciate some of the basic elements of water science.

So says Environment Minister Dr Nick Smith.

He says people need to understand that all our water bodies have different issues – be they nutrients, bacteria or sediment. Smith says overall water quality in NZ is very good.

"When I hear people saying that every water body must be swimmable those are slogans rather than substance and slogans will not improve water quality," he told Rural News. "Not every water body in NZ was swimmable before people arrived in NZ.

"The reality is that every water body in a flood will have faecal coliforms counts that make them unsafe to swim."

Smith says the science around water quality is challenging because each of our water bodies have different issues and that there is no single, magic bullet fix for a complex problem. He says another issue – which is hard to communicate – is the hydrological cycle.

This refers to the time it takes for deep ground water to flow from point A to B. In some cases, it can take between 20 to 80 years for the effects of pollution to show up. He says in Nelson ground water polluted by a pig farm resulted in a local council having to spend $13 million on a new treatment plant.

The proposal to take the issue of managing stock exclusions away from regional councils may surprise some.

However, Smith says councils have been struggling with the complexity and politics of fresh water management.

"But I also think that central governments needs to put its hand up and say we have not provided sufficiently clear national direction," he says.

More like this

Double Standard

OPINION: The proverbial has really hit the fan in Wellington and exposed a glaring example of a double standard in environmental accountability.

Featured

Jessica Kilday wins BrightSIDE dairy scholarship

The South Island Dairy Event's BrightSIDE has named Jessica Kilday as the recipient of the BrightSIDE Scholarship, recognising her commitment to furthering her education and future career in the New Zealand dairy industry.

Cresslands Stud's Century of Change

The subdivision and sale of the Rangiora's Coldstream Estate in 1921 was advantageous for not one, but four Cantebury families - but one in particular has become synonymous with outstanding Holstein Friesian cattle.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Silly Season

OPINION: Election years are usually regarded as the silly season, but a mate of the Hound reckons 2026 is shaping…

Two-Faced System

OPINION: If farmers poured just a few litres of some pollutant into a stream, the Green Party and the wider…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter