Wednesday, 09 October 2019 13:24

NZ concerns over US-Japan FTA

Written by  Pam Tipa
Stephanie Honey says a potential US/Japan FTA would have negative impacts on NZ beef, port, wheat and cheese exports to Japan. Stephanie Honey says a potential US/Japan FTA would have negative impacts on NZ beef, port, wheat and cheese exports to Japan.

The US-JAPAN trade deal might impact on New Zealand beef, cheese and other exports to Japan and is almost certainly in breach of World Trade Organisation (WTO) rules, says a trade expert.

It will also lessen the incentive for other countries – including the US – to join the CPTPP, the 11-country Asia Pacific deal which New Zealand has signed up to. The US pulled out of that deal.

The US-Japan deal includes new market access for about $7 billion in US farm exports, according to fact sheets from the US trade representative

Japan will eliminate or lower tariffs -- and in some cases create new US-specific tariff rate quotas -- for a range of farm products including beef, pork, wheat and cheese, says NZ International Business Forum associate director Stephanie Honey. 

In return, the US will reduce or eliminate tariffs on a few dozen Japanese agriculture exports and on industrial goods including machine tools, fasteners, steam turbines and bicycles. 

Along with other elements “essentially this is the same ambitious outcome as CPTPP, but goes modestly further in some areas,” said Honey.

“The agriculture part of the deal explicitly replicates the earlier package in the CPTPP,” she told Rural News.  

“It means NZ will face increased competition in the Japanese market from US farm products – including beef (NZ exports of fresh and frozen beef were worth over $166 million last year), cheese ($381m), whey and whey products ($35m), wine ($14.5m) and a range of horticultural products including cherries ($381,000) and frozen processed potatoes ($3.3m).” 

Honey says more worrying is the ‘demonstration effect’.  

“Under GATT/WTO rules, free trade agreements (FTAs) must cover ‘substantially all the trade’ in order to be excused from the otherwise fundamental rule of ‘MFN’ (that is, not providing special favours to one trading partner over others).  

“The agreement reputedly covers over 90% of US food and agriculture exports to Japan, but agriculture  exports accounted for less than 10% of total US exports of goods and services to Japan.”  

It is hard to see how this deal meets the GATT benchmark, Honey adds.   

“How other [disadvantaged] trading partners react remains to be seen.”

It may be that the US and Japan will argue that this is simply an interim step on the way to a more comprehensive package, which is allowed under GATT rules, she says.

  “The signalling is clear, however.  Fundamental trade policy principles on non-discrimination, comprehensiveness and agreed rules (for example, enforcement) no longer seem to be a foregone conclusion.   

“We have already seen suggestions that the EU would want to exclude agriculture from any trade agreement with the US, and that the US would likewise contemplate post-Brexit ‘micro-deals’ with the UK.   

“None of this bodes well for tackling some of the more intransigent distortions in the global trading system, nor indeed for a producer of ‘sensitive’ products like New Zealand.”

ExportNZ executive director Catherine Beard says Japan will apply the same commitments it has made under CPTPP for import liberalisation for some US agriculture imports.  

“Unfortunately for NZ this includes beef and cheese and other products of interests.

“This agreement will therefore potentially see the US, once more, competing on a level playing field with NZ exporters in the Japan market.  This threatens to erode some of the most important gains achieved through CPTPP.”

The deal is potentially subject to challenge in the WTO, she says.

More like this

Quota split a major worry

New Zealand meat exporters want the EU and UK to get serious on reaching a deal on post-Brexit quotas.

Sino-Aus trade spat worsens

New Zealand should be carefully watching the unfolding trade war between Australia and China, says trade expert Stephen Jacobi.

A potential bogey for NZ/EU trade deal

The fallout from a golf match out in the west of Ireland could have negative repercussions on the outcome of New Zealand’s Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with the European Union.


Merlo goes greener

Obviously not wishing to get left behind by some of its competitors, Italian manufacturer Merlo is planning to add to its green-liveried telehandler range- with another set of green credentials in the shape of an all-new, all-electric battery-powered Merlo e-Worker model.


Growing a family legacy

What started with planting some acacia trees 25 years ago has become a multi-generational passion for the Hunt family in Te Awamutu.

Moves to improve winter grazing requirements

DairyNZ says it supports recommendations to the Government from an advisory group looking to improve winter grazing rules for farmers and achieve better environmental outcomes.


Machinery & Products

Good growth year for Claas

While many sectors of the agricultural machinery were hit by the ravages of Covid-19, the effects of the pandemic did…

Green machine frugal on fuel

According to the industry respected independent DLG PowerMix test, John Deere appears to be the best choice of tractor for…

App takes pressure off

TRS Tyre & Wheel, owned by Trelleborg Wheel Systems, has introduced the TLC Plus App to the New Zealand market.

New MF 5S series arrives

Just before Christmas, Massey Ferguson quietly released details of the successor to its popular MF 5700S range in the shape…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound


Your old mate reckons the nomination of the New Zealand Dairy Industry Awards (NZDIA) management team as a finalists in…

Good riddance!

The Hound reckons 2021 is off to a rollicking start with news that professional whinger and anti-farming drone Martin Taylor…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter