Four-Year Trial Confirms Plantain Cuts N Losses 33%
A four year trial has reaffirmed that mixing plantain into dairy pastures can help reduce nitrogen losses to freshwater while maintaining milk production and profitability, say researchers.
The project, led by Dr James Millner, Academic Dean - Agriculture, at Massey University, was launched in 2019. It currently has three trial sites for a range of native shrubs, looking at palatability, digestibility, protein content and other nutritional charactersistics as well as the Mātauranga Māori (Māori knowledge) for a range of species.
Hill Country Futures is a long-term $8.1m programme focused on future proofing the profitability, sustainabiity and wellbeing of New Zealand's hill country farmers, their farm systems, the environment and rural communities.
Overall, the research focuses include improving animal productivity, animal welfare, biodiversity and soil health, while mitigating soil eroision and climate change.
Millner says the programme is assessing the productivity and seasonal growth patterns of indigenous species potentially useful as occasional 'browse species'.
These are Houhere (Hoheria populnea), Pāpāuma (Griselinia liteoralis), Karo (Pittosporum crassifolium), Karamū (Coprosma robusta), Whauwhaupaku (Pseudopanax arboreus), Māhoe (Melicytus ramiforus) and Taupata (Coprosma repens).
The non-native Salix Kinuyanagi, a browse willow, has been included and can be compared with the natives.
"Culturally, native shrub species have long histories and the team is building that knowledge into this project," he explains.
"We are interested in giving hill country farmers as many options as possible and are specifically looking at the potential of native shrubs as forage in hill country."
Millner says farmers with steep erosion-prone land may be interested in getting it into woody vegetation.
"Pinus radiata is one option commonly used but not everyone wants to be a forester. Transport and harvesting in steep areas is also expensive so it may not be economically feasible," he says.
"There are potential economic benefits to planting native shrubs, along with enhanced diversity, improved water quality and reduced erosion. We are looking at the additional potential benefits for forage and for grazing sheep around the shrubs."
The native shrubs selected are known to be heavily browsed in areas where there are deer and goats, suggesting they would be palatable to sheep.
"We are also looking into nutritional traits," Millner adds.
"For instance, the protein content and any tanins that can affect how protein is digested, and if there are any anthelmintic - natural anti-parasite - qualities, as there is evidence some shrubs have that effect."
The research is also looking at what happens during in vitro digestion to see how much methane and CO2 is produced in the rumen.
Currently, the project has three hill country trial sites on farms, two in the Manawatu and one on the Mahia Peninsula.
"We have discovered that the foliage of the shrubs is pretty digestible and we don't think there will be any problem with sheep browsing on it," Millner says.
"It is a bit low in protein, so not good for long-term feed or for young animals that farmers are needing to grow quickly, but there would be no problem at all with short-term maintenance feeding.
"In summer, it could provide a short-term food resource to fall back on when dry and shelter, particularly after shearing - alongside the environmental and economic benefits."
He adds that research into anthelmintic work is due to start soon. Food preference trials are due to get started in the autumn and full feeding trials in spring 2022. That will be followed by feeding trials.
"The sheep food preference trials will involve us offering standard feeds like lucerne chaff as well as leaves from the shrubs to see if the sheep will voluntarily eat them," Millner says.
"We'll take data from that as the basis for a proper feeding trial and measure dry matter in and dry matter out. Ultimately, we want to grow some shrubs in paddocks with sheep, however this will be subject to approval by an animal ethics committee."
Millner believes the main disincentive to planting hill country with native shrubs would be the cost - at $4-$5 per shrub, plus the cost of planting out and initial weed control. This would need to be weighed against the potential benefits, including income carbon credits.
"The initial outlay can be >$10,000/ha - limiting widespread uptake unless assistance from central or regional government was available," he explains.
"Our aim is to provide robust information that can give farmers, their bankers and others the information they need to have confidence that it is a good thing to do, so they can weigh up the cost and the benefits."
