Tuesday, 11 April 2023 10:55

Morrison takes loss on the chin but throws parting bomb

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Former Beef+Lamb NZ chair Andrew Morrison (r) with chief executive Sam McIvor at last month’s AGM. Former Beef+Lamb NZ chair Andrew Morrison (r) with chief executive Sam McIvor at last month’s AGM.

It was a unique Beef+Lamb New Zealand annual general meeting in New Plymouth.

There were nine remits, scathing about how B+LNZ leaders are handling discussions to reduce on-farm emissions, and a motion of no confidence against the board.

Chairing the meeting was Gore farmer Andrew Morrison, who was days earlier voted off the board and chairmanship by southern South Island sheep and beef farmers.

Speaking to Rural News after the AGM, Morrison agreed that it was "quite a unique day".

"I was voted out, but you still have to chair the meeting," he says.

Morrison was defeated by Southland sheep and beef farmer Geoffrey Young, who received 8,777 weighted votes against 6,587 votes for Morrison - a winning margin of 2,190 votes.

The southern South Island electorate covers the Southland region and Clutha district. Morrison was first elected to B+LNZ in 2014 and became the chair in 2018.

He says losing to Young was not a surprise in one way.

"Of course, no one wants to lose an election. But if you look at election process globally post pandemic, people have voted for change," Morrison told Rural News. "But we value our democracy."

Morrison was critical of what he called lies and misinformation spread by people including some in rural media.

"I have always stood in front and taken all the bullets and I would challenge reporters to put their names to everything they report."

Morrison believes B+LNZ has done some great work on behalf of farmers over the last six years.

He points out that concerns raised at the AGM were around its advocacy position on just one subject - He Waka Eke Noa.

"None of us are surprised because this is the most complex debate that every country and sector is having," he explains.

"To put things into context, that's what we were sitting with at the AGM - nine remits and a vote of no confidence related to HWEN."

Morrison says he wears the farmer backlash on the chin.

"We haven't had the ability to take them on the climate change journey and the best system to facilitate that journey."

Asked if he would have done anything different in hindsight, Morrison says he would have liked the Government to have given them more time.

"More time for the most complex debate, starting up a world first in agriculture emissions reporting," he adds.

"I think all of us have been naïve as to how big a job this was going to be, both in building and taking our sectors along with us."

Morrison said he met with a bunch of kiwifruit growers the other day.

"They haven't even started any of these conversations because they have still got nitrous oxide impacts.

"It's not criticising them, but saying this is a hell of a challenge for multiple sectors."

Personally, Morrison thinks working with other sectors is the way forward.

"The relationships of sectors and trust are imperative and success for all sectors is actually the same," he says.

"We identify what our issues are and then basically own our issues as sectors and then facilitate the solution."

Morrison believes there is confusion that some sectors are being treated harshly.

"I would contest we need to spend more time and get all our levy payers understanding that, because I challenge them that's not the case."

Morrison says he will now spend more time with family and concentrate on his other governance roles in agriculture.

More like this

Potential threats to our reputation

South Waikato farmer Helen Mandeno recently delivered a speech at Beef + Lamb NZ's annual meeting in Nelson. She spoke in support of her remit on B+LNZ seeking majority consensus from levy payers before advancing policies that may threaten NZ's pure, grass-fed and non-GE status. Here's part of what she said:

App trial yields promising results

An initial trial of an app, funded by Beef + Lamb New Zealand, has demonstrated significant results in reducing drench inputs during a small-scale study.

Not so bad!

OPINION: Your old mate is still somewhat gobsmacked by sheer stupidity and lack of understanding by Beef+Lamb NZ’s board in asking for a pay rise at this year’s annual meeting.

Featured

Demand for food support increases

New findings from not-for-profit food supply and distribution organization, the New Zealand Food Network (NZFN) have revealed a 42% increase in demand for food support in 2023 compared to 2022.

Herd production performance soars

New data released by LIC and DairyNZ shows New Zealand dairy farmers have achieved the highest six week in-calf rate and lowest notin- calf rate on record.

Council lifeline for A&P Show

Christchurch City Council and the Canterbury Agricultural and Pastoral Association (CAPA) have signed an agreement which will open more of Canterbury Agricultural Park for public use while helping to provide long-term certainty for the A&P Show.

Rural Advocacy Hub announced for Fieldays

This year’s Fieldays will feature a Rural Advocacy Hub - bringing together various rural organisations who are advocating for farmers and championing their interests as one team, under one roof, for the first time.

Struggling? Give us a call

ASB head of rural banking Aidan Gent is encouraging farmers to speak to their banks when they are struggling.

National

Rural Change to merge with RST

The Rural Change programme, providing free private mental health professional sessions to the rural industry, is set to continue its…

Machinery & Products

Factory clocks up 60 years

There can't be many heavy metal fans who haven’t heard of Basildon, situated about 40km east of London and originally…

PM opens new Power Farming facility

Morrinsville based Power Farming Group has launched a flagship New Zealand facility in partnership with global construction manufacturer JCB Construction.

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Cut with care

OPINION: The new government has clearly signalled big cuts across the public service.

Bubble burst!

OPINION: Your canine crusader is not surprised by the recent news that New Zealand plant-based ‘fake meat’ business is in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter