Wednesday, 17 November 2021 06:55

Lukewarm response from investors

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Fonterra fund manager John Sherwin (left) with former Agriculture MInister Nathan Guy. Fonterra fund manager John Sherwin (left) with former Agriculture MInister Nathan Guy.

Fonterra unit holders have given a lukewarm response to the co-op's proposed capital structure.

They are disappointed that Fonterra rejected their recommendation that the fund be sold to unit holders at fair value. However, they've welcomed the proposal to cap the overall size of the fund at 10% of total Fonterra shares on issue rather than at the current size of around 6.7%.

In a letter to unit holders sent last week, fund chairman John Sherwin says capping the fund at 10% goes part way to addressing the size-related concerns.

"Subject to the Fonterra board's approval, the amended proposal provides the scope for the fund to be increased in size at a suitable time in the future to address the liquidity and other size-related considerations," he says.

"While it is disappointing that no progress has been made on the buyback recommendation, the subcommittee welcomes Fonterra's decision to modify it's recommendation around the capping of the fund."

Fonterra's farmer shareholders will vote on the new capital structure next month. Details will be released and mailed to farmers this week, then voting starts on November 19.

A special meeting will follow Fonterra's annual general meeting on December 9 for the vote. The proposal requires 75% support among voting shareholders to pass.

The proposal has already passed one hurdle - the requirement of a 50% yes vote by the Fonterra Co-operative Council (the old Shareholders Council).

Fonterra chairman Peter McBride says the council has already voted 92% in support of the recommended changes.

The co-operative has made several changes to the capital structure proposal put forward in September. The future of the fund has been a key issue.

McBride says the overall limit on the size of the fund has been reduced from 20% to 10% of total shares on issue, rather than having a total ban on any further shares being exchanged into units.

"This recognises that the fund size, which is currently around 6.7% of total shares on issue, could change from time to time subject to the overall limit," McBride claims. "Shares will still not be able to be exchanged into units on a day-to-day basis, and the board retains its current rights to regulate this process."

The fund, capped at $500m, has been a disappointment for investors who paid for units in return for dividends. Poor investment decisions by Fonterra and a lack of earnings have resulted in disappointing investment returns.

Key Changes to Capital Structure

  • The introduction of thresholds to support the alignment of share ownership and milk supply, and reflect Fonterra's intention that the total number of shares on issue in the co-op is within +/- 15% of total milk supply, and that the proportion of shares held by ceased suppliers is less than 25% of the shares in the co-op.
  • The way dry shares are allocated to associated shareholders (sharemilkers, contract milkers and farm lessors) has been simplified to make it easier for them to apply to hold dry shares.
  • The overall limit on the size of the Fund has been reduced from 20% to 10% of total shares on issue, rather than having a total ban on any further shares being exchanged into units.

More like this

A Year of Delivery for Fonterra

Fonterra’s 2026 financial year was a year of delivery, with record volumes of milk collected, processed and shipped by the co-op.

Featured

Students' Strobe Light Targets Nesting Birds in Tractors

During the nesting season, from September to December, industrious starlings can quickly build nests in the darker areas behind tractor and vehicle, usually close to hot engines, typically resulting in localised damage or in some cases complete write-offs.

NZ Tractor Deliveries Up 5% Year to Date to September

With the last couple of months having seen some potential tractor purchases put on hold with the impending election and continued input cost rises, year-to-date figures, ending September, has seen deliveries up around 5% over the same period in 2025, with a total of 2026 units.

MPI's Diana Reaich on Non-Tariff Barriers and Trade Access

The head of the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) trade and international relations group says New Zealand is well-positioned to secure trade access and compete internationally as the world becomes more complicated, demanding and uncertain.

National

Machinery & Products

Claas Balers Turn 30

Claas built its first variable chamber round baler - the Variant 100 - in 1996, so 2026 marks 30 years…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

'LinkedIn Greens'

OPINION: The same mainstream media muppets that brought you Jacindamania in 2017 have been flat out pimping for the Opportunities…

UK Warning

OPINION: Your old mate reckons the atrocious way farmers in the UK are treated by their lords and masters in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter