Tuesday, 20 November 2018 10:55

Fonterra election process raises questions

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
She’s back – re-elected Fonterra director Leonie Guiney with husband Kieran at the co-op’s annual meeting earlier this month. She’s back – re-elected Fonterra director Leonie Guiney with husband Kieran at the co-op’s annual meeting earlier this month.

Fonterra's inconclusive director election is raising questions among shareholders.

As predicted in the last Rural News, the revised director voting threw a hung result: only two candidates passed the 50% ‘yes’ vote threshold, leaving one director vacancy unfilled.

Federated Farmers Waikato president Andrew McGiven believes the election process needs better transparency.

Expressing surprise that the co-op only elected two directors to fill three board vacancies, McGiven says shareholders are demanding clarification.

“There is still a lot of conjecture around this, hence the dissatisfaction among shareholders who nominated the two outside candidates,” he says.

“I think the farmer message to the board is that they are accountable to us as shareholders.  I don’t know why the other two board nominees were not elected, but I think there is a clear message to the board -- and to a certain extent senior management -- that they aren’t greater than Fonterra itself, and in the end are accountable to us as shareholders and suppliers.”

Five candidates contested the board elections; the board backed three candidates through the independent nomination process: sitting director Ashley Waugh and new candidates Peter McBride and Jamie Tuuta.

Two candidates -- Leonie Guiney and John Nicholls -- were nominated by farmers. Only McBride and Guiney were successful.

Guiney, who served a three-year term on the board, thanks shareholders for trusting her.

“I take that responsibility very seriously; it’s a very strong mandate, a mandate to protect the coop’s assets for the long term, but also to reallocate our resources to where we are most competitive,” she told Rural News.

“For me this was the test of whether farmers were engaged enough to create constructive change. They are: 68% came out and voted. 

“When co-op members care enough to vote the co-op has a future, and when the board members have a strong mandate from their members the board can get on with their job while retaining one of the greatest advantages a co-op has -- loyal supply.”

Guiney had a testy relationship with the previous chairman John Wilson; a court case between Guiney and the board over alleged leaking of confidential information was settled out-of-court after Wilson stepped down as chairman in July.

McBride, the outgoing chairman of Zespri, was overwhelmed with the response in the election.

“I want farmers to know I will do my very best and I will work hard for them,” he told Rural News. “It was a good result. I was quite surprised at the outcome with only two people making it through but I guess that is the system.”

He says going into the election he was concerned the farmers may “just see me as a kiwifruit guy”. 

“But I think when they got to meet me in person and heard what I had to say then they understood I had something to offer.”

Waugh, a sitting director, refused to comment on his ousting from the board.

Biggest losers

So, who are the biggest losers from the flawed Fonterra director election process?

The two board-backed candidates Ashley Waugh and Jamie Tuuta- who exposed themselves to the rigorous process and were hung out to dry.

The shareholder Council, which ran the process. The system is flawed and the council got the mood of the farmers completely wrong.

The independent assessment panel who vetted possible candidates and recommended three candidates to the board. Only one candidate was successful. Why would these top business minds offer themselves to sit on a committee, whose recommendation is ignored by farmers?

More like this

Winston Peters questions Fonterra divestment plan

Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has joined the debate around the proposed sale of Fonterra’s consumer and related businesses, demanding answers from the co-operative around its milk supply deal with the buyer, Lactalis.

Editorial: A new era for two co-ops

OPINION: Farmer shareholders of two of New Zealand's largest co-operatives have an important decision to make this month and what they decide could change the landscape of the dairy and meat sectors in New Zealand.

Should co-op sell its consumer brands?

OPINION: As CEO of the Dairy Board in the 1980s I was fortunate to work with a team of experienced and capable executives who made most of the brand investments that created the international consumer business Fonterra inherited. Soprole in Chile was the largest, but there were more than 20 countries where consumer marketing companies were established and Anchor and other brands were successfully launched.

Featured

Winston Peters questions Fonterra divestment plan

Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has joined the debate around the proposed sale of Fonterra’s consumer and related businesses, demanding answers from the co-operative around its milk supply deal with the buyer, Lactalis.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Quid prod quo?

OPINION: Ageing lefty Chris Trotter reckons that the decision to delay recognition of Palestinian statehood is more than just a fit…

Deadwood

OPINION: A mate of yours truly recently met someone at a BBQ who works at a big consulting firm who spent…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter