Farmer wins four-year stoush with council
Te Anau Downs Station owner Peter Chartres has won a four-year, $1 million legal battle with the Southland District Council (SDC).
Te Anau Downs Station owner Peter Chartes - who won a four-year legal battle with the Southland District Council (SDC) last October - has now received a $300,000 payout from the council.
SDC went to the Environment Court last April seeking an enforcement order to prevent any further indigenous vegetation clearance on the station and also requiring significant remedial work. However, in October 2022, the court released a detailed 107 page decision declining the council's application for an enforcement order.
At the time, Chartres welcomed the ruling clearing him of unlawful clearances dating back to 2001, saying the council's approach had been "overzealous".
SDC had accused Chartres of unlawful clearance activities dating back to 2001. However, it failed to prove that there had been any breach of the relevant biodiversity rules that applied since that time.
In a statement, SDC chief executive Cameron McIntosh said the council accepted the judgement.
"This has highlighted the difficulties of operating in the realm of the Resource Management Act and associated government regulations," he added. "In the New Year we intend to raise these matters with the Ministry for the Environment to highlight the complexities of the situation."
However, Chartres told Rural News it was disappointing to read McIntosh's comments on the decision.
"He blames 'the difficulties of operating in the realm of the Resource Management Act and associated government regulations' for the council's failure in these enforcement proceedings," Chartres explained.
"Council's failure in this case was clearly spelt out by the Environment Court in its decision where it found that SDC had not established any breach of the rules."
Chartres says it was SDC's "complete failure to provide any evidence to the court to support its allegations of a breach of the rules" that resulted in the court finding in his favour
"This has nothing to do with the Resource Management Act and associated regulations as claimed by Mr McIntosh, and nor does the court's decision identify this as a problem," he added.
"As the court found, the real issue was that the council did not correctly apply or even understand its own district plan rules, and nor did it ever try to understand or engage with my consistently expressed position on existing use rights."
Chartres believes the decision awarding him $300,000 in costs "is a vindication of my position and reflects the failings of the Council's case and their conduct".
"It is disappointing that the ratepayers will have to bear the $300,000 costs awarded to me and the more than $500,000 costs that the council spent on its case."
Chartres told Rural News his family has farmed Te Anau Downs Station since 1925 and that around 78% of the original farm had ben appropriated to the conservation estate without compensation.
Dawn Meats is set to increase its proposed investment in Alliance Group by up to $25 million following stronger than forecast year-end results by Alliance.
A day after the ouster of PGG Wrightson’s chair and his deputy, the listed rural trader’s board has appointed John Nichol as the new independent chair.
Tributes are pouring in from across the political divide for former Prime Minister Jim Bolger who passed away, aged 90.
The iconic services building at National Fieldays' Mystery Creek site will be demolished to make way for a "contemporary replacement that better serves the needs of both the community and event organisers," says board chair Jenni Vernon.
Agri advisor Perrin Ag says its graduate recruitment programme continues to bring new talent into the agricultural sector.
Entries are open for the 2026 New Zealand Dairy Industry Awards (NZDIA).
OPINION: Ageing lefty Chris Trotter reckons that the decision to delay recognition of Palestinian statehood is more than just a fit…
OPINION: A mate of yours truly recently met someone at a BBQ who works at a big consulting firm who spent…