Sunday, 10 May 2015 00:00

Aussie sheep industry hits back at extremists

Written by 
Australia wool sector has hit back at PETA’s fake shearing campaign. Australia wool sector has hit back at PETA’s fake shearing campaign.

Extremist animal welfare group PETA’s campaign (Rural News, April 21) against the Australian wool industry has led to a number of advocacy groups in the sector taking action against its misleading promotion.

The furore surrounds an advertisement featuring Australian musician Jona Weinhofen clutching what appears to be the fake, bleeding body of a violently sheared sheep, carrying the slogan: “Here’s the rest of your wool coat.”

The advertisement was released in conjunction with video footage of sheep being treated poorly in shearing sheds.

PETA claimed the advertisement represented the “realities of the Australian wool industry” and that “25% of the world’s wool comes from Australia and it’s made from 100% cruelty”.

The advertisement, which aired earlier this month, has been met with outrage from many who believe the campaign is misleading.

“It’s a false image, backed by false and insulting claims,” Victorian Farmers Federation Livestock Group president Ian Feldtmann says.

“It’s in our own interest to treat our animals humanely, given good treatment means healthy animals and good productivity. All Australians should realise that PETA is all about portraying extreme behaviour as the norm.”

Leading wool industry group WoolProducers Australia has also condemned the advertisement and refuted the animal welfare activitists’ claims.

“Australian wool growers protect the health and welfare of their sheep through a variety of animal husbandry practices that are suited to the sheep type and the environment,” WoolProducers Australia said in a statement.

“Sheep producers are continually investing in sheep health and welfare. Over the last five years, more than $50 million has been spent on research and development, biosecurity, health and welfare programmes.

“Wool growers tend to their sheep every day, using appropriate and often world leading husbandry and management practices.”

The campaign has prompted the VFF to lodge a complaint with the Advertising Standards Bureau, with its complaint focusing on the fake representation of the lamb as “misleading and offensive”.

But while some farming groups are pushing for the ad to be removed by bureaucratic means, the Western Australian Farmers Federation is instead campaigning to educate Weinhofen and PETA through a crowd-funding campaign.

WAFarmers launched its campaign to send Weinhofen to shearing school by aiming to raise $4500.

If it meets the mark, then WA Farmers president Dale Park says he would extend the invitation to the staff at PETA – including the chief executive and the marketing department – to clarify any misconceptions they may have.

“No one that I know would shear a lamb that size – it looks a day old – and certainly they wouldn’t tolerate such a low standard of shearing,” Park says. 

He says the PETA campaign preys on people who have no knowledge of shearing practices. “Shearers are trained in best practice technique and any shearer that did that to a sheep would be out of a job.”

» Connect with Rural News

More like this

Dairy welfare code revamped

The code of welfare for dairy cattle has been amended to address behavioural needs and off-paddock systems, says the National Animal Welfare Advisory Committee (NAWAC).

» The RNG Weather Report



A lesson in political science

The Zero Carbon Bill has just been passed into law, but not without significant misgivings from across the farming sector.

RMA not good enough

New Zealand's natural environment is now much more degraded than when the Resource Management Act was developed in 1991.

Fonterra chairman feels the heat

Frustrated Fonterra farmers called for chairman John Monaghan to take responsibility for the co-op’s financial debacle and step down.

» Connect with Rural News

» Connect with Rural News

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Job hunting?

A mate of the Hound reckons outgoing special agricultural trade envoy Mike Petersen, who is due to finish his current…

Hot air?

With the Government wanting to implement huge costs on the livestock farming sector by making New Zealand the only country…

» Connect with Rural News