Thursday, 27 October 2022 07:55

Editorial: What were they thinking?

Written by  Staff Reporters
Could the Government's emissions plan mark the end of beef farming in New Zealand? Could the Government's emissions plan mark the end of beef farming in New Zealand?

OPINION: The Government's so-called plan to price agricultural emissions must surely rank as one of the most bewildering decisions in the history of New Zealand farming.

This is about a proposal that could see many sheep and beef farmers' incomes cut by up to 20%. Making the sheep and beef sector unviable has huge implications. Farmers could well walk off their land and leave it to the 'plant and walk carbon farmers'.

If this wasn't bad enough, the group most likely to be affected is Māori. Ardern and her Green mates love to publically display their support for Māori and all the things they are doing for them, which no one can seriously argue about. Traditionally Labour has been strongly supported by Māori - but is this about to end?

Māori produce about 15% of the country's sheep and beef exports and Māori make up close to 30% of the workforce in meat processing plants. Their asset base in the sheep and beef sector is over $8 billion.

Federated Farmers president Andrew Hoggard and other commentators are on the money when they say the present Government's proposal will wipe out a large part of heartland NZ and will cause massive economic and social consequences in rural communities, especially the East Coast and the centre of the North Island where there are large numbers of Māori farms.

Freezing works could well close and already poor communities could become destitute. All for the sake, some say, of giving the PM the chance to prance around on the world stage in Red Bands and say, "We are first to tax our farmers". While the rest of the world will continue polluting on!

The government line is that most of the recommendations by a consortium of the rural sector have been accepted, and that's probably correct, but it's the crazy changes it is proposing to these recommendations that beggars belief. How long will it be before we are importing lamb, not exporting it to China, or buying beef, not selling beef to the USA? It might sound dramatic, but the risk is, it could be true - not to mention massive unemployment in rural NZ.

One has to feel a bit sorry for Agriculture Minister Damien O'Connor who (to rework his own phrase) seems caught between a 'gaggle of greens and chardonnay-swigging socialists'.

Nice act Arder, on the international stage, but spare a thought for heartland NZ, which is seemingly being flushed down the dunny.

More like this

Editorial: Marlborough's viticulture evolution

OPINION: When I moved to Marlborough two decades ago, I found countless lines of tidy vines, neatly mowed and carefully sprayed, with diligent conventional practices interspersed with the odd organic or cover-cropping outlier, like Te Whare Ra.

Editorial: Getting RMA settings right

OPINION: The Government has been seeking industry feedback on its proposed amendments to a range of Resource Management Act (RMA) national direction instruments.

Editorial: Agri's mojo is back

OPINION: Good times are coming back for the primary industries. From sentiment expressed at Fieldays to the latest rural confidence survey results, all indicate farmer confidence at a near-record high.

Featured

Synlait, Nestlé Expand Eco-Focused Dairy Partnership in NZ

A partnership between Canterbury milk processor Synlait and the world's largest food producer, Nestlé, has been celebrated with a visit to a North Canterbury farm by a group including senior staff from Synlait, the Ravensdown subsidiary EcoPond, and Nestlé's Switzerland head office.

National

Machinery & Products

Chinese Tractors Eye Western Europe

Having caused quite a stir at last year’s Agritechnica, Chinese manufacturer Zoomlion is reported to be conducting large-scale field trials…

Franz Grimme Turns 80

Franz Grimme recently celebrated his 80th birthday earlier March and continues to be an entrepreneur with passion and pioneering spirit,…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

What A Choice!

OPINION: If you ask this old mutt, the choice at the next election isn't shaping up as a contest of…

Your Call!

OPINION: A mate of yours says we're long overdue for a reckoning on what value farmers really get for the…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter