Fonterra consumer business sale price jumps to $4.22b
The sale price of Fonterra’s global consumer and associated businesses to the world’s largest dairy company Lactalis has risen to $4.22 billion.
Fonterra's market share could fall from 84% to 79% over the next five years, says TDB Advisory, financial and economic advisors.
The ‘New Zealand Dairy Companies Review’ published in April says it seems likely that Fonterra’s competitors, with well-established relationships with farmer-suppliers and offshore customers and profitable operations, will have access to capital to permit them to continue growing at rates of about 10% per annum.
“If, as we assume to be the case, Fonterra grows by 2.5% per annum, Fonterra’s market share will fall from 84% to 79% over the next five years.”
It says the market share of NZ milk processing companies in 2016 was Fonterra 84%, Open Country Dairy 6%, Westland 3%, Synlait 3%, Miraka 1%, Oceania 1% and Tatua 1%.
“The NZ milk processing industry remains predominantly low risk with the large majority of volumes in commodities,” the report says.
“Competitors to Fonterra have improved the transparency of the sector’s risks and returns. The higher-risk strategies (Tatua and Synlait) are being adequately rewarded while at the other end of the spectrum OCD is generating returns materially above its (low-risk) cost of capital.”
Earlier the report says Fonterra’s NZ milk-processing competitors are now well established.
“The competitors’ milk volumes have grown from 600 million litres when Fonterra was established in 2002 to 2.9 billion litres in 2016.
“They now have a combined profitability (EBIT) of over $200m. Interestingly, Fonterra has grown its Australian milk processing volumes to 1.7b litres over the same period and in 2016 delivered a normalised EBIT on its Australian operations of $63m.”
Open Country Dairy is the benchmark commodity processor and Tatua the benchmark value-added processor.
“Both are focussed on their core businesses and delivering higher than expected risk-weighted returns to their shareholders and farmers. Both are paying some of the excess return to farmer-suppliers. When we normalise their cost of milk to Fonterra’s FGMP, their returns on assets in 2016 were 22% (Tatua) and 17% (OCD).
“Synlait is successfully shifting more of its milk into higher margin returns and has the access to capital and confidence from recent returns on assets of above 10% to invest in higher-value manufacturing assets that will continue its growth in volume and margin.
“Westland is the underperforming Fonterra competitor, and it is difficult to see that it could get shareholder support to invest more capital in higher-value processing assets.
“Westland has acknowledged its underperformance and we would expect little milk volume growth until it reduces its costs and regains the confidence of its shareholders.
“The balance sheets of Tatua and OCD show how significantly different their investment in long-term fixed-processing assets is.”
Tatua invests 250% more than OCD for every unit of milk processed, the report says.
“This additional investment is an indicator of the increased risk attached to a value-add strategy and underscores that a higher value-add strategy is not as simple as it sounds. It takes investment in long-term trusted customer relationships and investment in manufacturing assets that cost a lot more than is required for a commodity processor.
“If Tatua’s investment in manufacturing per unit of milk is applied to the other NZ dairy processors (including Fonterra’s NZ milk volumes), an additional $8b in capital would be required across the sector.”
The TBD Advisory report says given comments from the companies “we think it is reasonable to assume the current strategic positioning of the companies will remain the same over the coming few years”.
The New Zealand Food Network's (NZFN) fifth birthday celebrations have been boosted by a whopping five tonne meat donation from meat processor ANZCO.
Pukekohe vegetable growers farewelled 101-year-old Alan Wilcox in late July, celebrating his many achievements and reflecting the widespread respect in which he was held.
A new nationwide survey shows New Zealanders expect farmers and food producers to play a leading role in cutting greenhouse gas emissions, but also gave them higher marks than most industries for their current efforts.
North Otago farmer Jane Smith is standing for the Ravensdown South Island director seat.
"Unwelcome" is how the chief executive of the Horticulture Export Authority (HEA), Simon Hegarty, describes the 15% tariff that the US has imposed on primary exports to that country.
Fertiliser co-operative Ballance has written down $88 million - the full value of its Kapuni urea plant in Taranaki - from its balance sheet in the face of a looming gas shortage.
OPINION: Your old mate gets the sinking feeling that no matter who we vote into power in the hope they…
OPINION: Newsroom is running a series of articles looking into the influence of lobbying and has kicked it off with…