Tuesday, 18 September 2012 16:50

Cowboy traders riding into sunset

Written by 

COWBOY TRADERS in the China infant formula market are a short-term phenomenon, says dairy analyst Tim Morris.

He says Chinese authorities are getting their act together and working towards stringent rules similar to those in US and Europe where cowboy traders have no chance of success.

His comments come as infant formula exports to China face growing scrutiny. MPI is investigating whether proper procedures for such products are being followed. And the marketing tactics of some importers in China are causing concern for authorities and exporters here.

Morris, director of Auckland firm Coriolis, believes these issues will play themselves out. China’s fascination for branded infant formula from overseas, rather than Chinese fomula, has given rise to cowboy traders, he says.

 But their success will be limited by Chinese authorities tightening regulations.  “You can’t ride into town with infant formula and ride off with a bucket of money,” he told Rural News. About 30 firms export New Zealand-made infant formula; Morris predicts two-thirds of these will be out of business within five years.

Auckland supermarkets were caught last year selling baby milk formula to Chinese exporters thousands of cans at a time while rationing them to other shoppers. This bulk trade was unknown to export authorities at the time. 

An MPI spokesman told Rural News it has been investigating infant formula exports to China for some time but will not comment further until the investigations are over.

A premium has attached in China to New Zealand-made dairy products since the melamine tainted-milk scandal in 2008, when six children died and nearly 1000 were hospitalised after melamine was added to formula supposedly to increase protein content.

Morris says New Zealand’s image survived the melamine scandal although it engulfed Fonterra’s Chinese operations. “The Chinese trust our infant formula and they travel to Hong Kong to buy global brands rather than Chinese brands.” This has led to an increase in some Chinese traders falsely labelling their products as ‘NZ made’.

The Infant Nutrition Council, representing most Australian and New Zealand infant formula exporters, knows of widespread concern among members. Chief executive Jan Carey says New Zealand milk and ‘Brand NZ’ are highly prized by Chinese consumers. 

“The New Zealand brand is trusted and considered best quality. Some Chinese marketers will use any marketing trick to promote their ‘Brand NZ’ whether genuine or not. This is a widespread problem. The Infant Nutrition Council, the New Zealand Government and the Chinese Government are aware of this.”

Carey says it is helping in MPI’s investigation. Though infant formula trade from New Zealand is properly regulated, “some middlemen are getting around the regulations”.

Featured

Students' Strobe Light Targets Nesting Birds in Tractors

During the nesting season, from September to December, industrious starlings can quickly build nests in the darker areas behind tractor and vehicle, usually close to hot engines, typically resulting in localised damage or in some cases complete write-offs.

NZ Tractor Deliveries Up 5% Year to Date to September

With the last couple of months having seen some potential tractor purchases put on hold with the impending election and continued input cost rises, year-to-date figures, ending September, has seen deliveries up around 5% over the same period in 2025, with a total of 2026 units.

MPI's Diana Reaich on Non-Tariff Barriers and Trade Access

The head of the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) trade and international relations group says New Zealand is well-positioned to secure trade access and compete internationally as the world becomes more complicated, demanding and uncertain.

National

Machinery & Products

Claas Balers Turn 30

Claas built its first variable chamber round baler - the Variant 100 - in 1996, so 2026 marks 30 years…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

'LinkedIn Greens'

OPINION: The same mainstream media muppets that brought you Jacindamania in 2017 have been flat out pimping for the Opportunities…

UK Warning

OPINION: Your old mate reckons the atrocious way farmers in the UK are treated by their lords and masters in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter