Risky business
OPINION: In the same way that even a stopped clock is right twice a day, economists sometimes get it right.
She was talking about the introduction of new environmental requirements and the threat of alternative proteins to dairy and the agriculture sector in general.
“If we don’t have economic sustainability in this country we will not have environmental sustainability,” she says.
Jones says you can put in all the regulation in the world but things will fall through the cracks of economic sustainability. “Without both of those we will never have social sustainability.”
And while she warned that change is coming faster than anyone realised, including the move towards alternative proteins, she says you have to also think about the well-being of farmers.
“Until something has happened to you which has a consequence, you tend not to do anything about it. That’s not the right way to be but it is a natural part of humans,” she says.
“We need to take people on the journey; that doesn’t mean we don’t have conversations, it doesn’t mean we are not honest and it doesn’t mean we are not hard. It means we don’t do the blame game, we don’t hammer people.
At the moment, farmers’ mental health is being severely affected, despite “people doing some fantastic things ….”
She says we need to celebrate the good, but not tolerate the bad.
“We need to be conscious of the people, the human aspect… we need to take people on this journey -- understand where they are coming from and what they are scared of. You’ve got to keep in mind, as soon as you say ‘alternative protein’ it tells someone they no longer have relevance….
“I think we need to be a little careful, a little cautious; though this doesn’t mean we don’t keep talking about it ….”
At the same time, she says, we are going to have scary conversations. “You need to show people how it can help them.”
Earlier in her presentation Jones said her role is to help people understand change and move quickly. The world is moving much faster than we thought and people are not keeping up with that change, including towards alternative proteins.
‘Value-add’ is an overused word, very much like sustainability. “If you think of a value-add customer or a premium customer, imagine a pyramid upside down.
“At the bottom I still expect the food to be safe, I’ll spend a little more money on something that is going to be good for me and I will spend even more on something that has a positive mutual impact on animals, environment and people.
“We will pay even more money at the top of the upside-down pyramid if what you are producing is really regenerating the environment.
“I think there is enough science there that [shows] we can’t add any more animals, or if we do we have to be very smart. It will take a lot of technology to make sure we do it the right way.”
She has eaten an Impossible Burger made of plant based material that could not be distinguished from meat.
California-based Perfect Day has learnt how to make milk out of casein DNA: they inject it into yeast and it grows itself into vegan milk.
“For New Zealand it is about finding that balance; I don’t think it needs to be all or nothing; I don’t think we need to shut down farming all together… it is about finding a balance.
