Print this page
Wednesday, 22 June 2022 08:55

Rural water concerns remain

Written by  David Anderson
Rural water users still remain concerned about the Government's contentious Three Waters reforms. Rural water users still remain concerned about the Government's contentious Three Waters reforms.

Rural water users still remain highly concerned about the Government's contentious Three Waters Reforms.

Worries still linger despite a recent report by the Rural Supplies Technical Working Group (RSTWG), which made 30 recommendations - including that the country's 100 or so council-owned rural water supply schemes be transferred into the four new mega water entities. RSTWG also suggested that the tens of thousands of privately-owned rural water supply schemes around NZ not be included in Three Waters reforms.

However, West Otago farmer and member on the Glenkenich rural water scheme, Hugh Gardyne, told Rural News that it "still looks like a loaded gun".

"When the Territorial Local Authorities (TLAs) hand over their urban Three Waters schemes - infrastructure control, staff capacity and capability as well as financial resources - to the Water Services Entities (the four mega entitities) then they are unable to support Rural Water Schemes going forward," he explains.

Gardyne's concerns echo those of Waimate District Council chief executive Stuart Duncan who believes the RSTWG scope was limited due to the Government's overarching reform objectives.

"The working group's terms of reference was limited, for example, recommending that all council-owned rural schemes transfer to the entities," he told Rural News. "With full knowledge that councils could not continue to operate the remote schemes if the urban schemes were removed, taking with it the bulk of the service equipment, assets and human resources."

Gardyne says some rural water schemes are unsubsidised (by local councils) but will still get treated alike.

"TLAs will have Rural Water Schemes (RWS) disposed from them but retain a charade of a structure as a conduit with Water Services Entities (WSE)," he adds. "It is my opinion and conclusion that all the RWSs subject to the new WSE structure, should be treated individually."

Gardyne says RWSs should be allowed, on a case-by-case basis, a referendum to determine if users want to be transferred to a WSE.

"RWSs would be better served with the option of 'end-point treatment' - even if that were at a public cost - to meet Taumata Arowai requirements"

Meanwhile, Duncan believe a more sensible approach would have been for the Government to draft subordinate legislation that firstly classified rural schemes and made provision (guidelines) for certain classes of scheme to be exempt from certain aspects of the New Zealand Drinking Water Standards.

"What is propose in this overall Three Waters Reform agenda carries very significant risk, both in terms of public health, cost to customers and future operating success."

More like this

Three Waters in trouble?

OPINION: Yet another sign has emerged that the Government's controversial Three Waters reform could be in trouble.

Govt provides Three Waters support for councils

Every Council in New Zealand will receive at least $350,000 of additional funding to ensure they have the resourcing necessary to implement the Three Waters reforms, Associate Minister of Local Government Kieran McAnulty announced today.

Council candidates deserve searching questions - Feds

With sweeping changes facing local government, and the very existence of some councils under threat, Federated Farmers is urging rural New Zealanders to step up their interest in the election campaign this year.

Dirty water

OPINION: The Hound reckons the Government's unpopular and controversial Three Waters reforms is creating plenty of jobs - for bureaucrats and contractors - but not for the local communities who are having their water assets stolen 'co-governed' and controlled by four new mega water entities.


Machinery & Products

New disc cultivator launched

Väderstad has introduced a new disc cultivator – the Carrier XT 425-625 – featuring rotating disc axles, that optimizes results…

JD unlocks its digital system

As a long-term advocate of digital technology, John Deere has taken the route of mass data capture, rather than concentrating…