fbpx
Print this page
Wednesday, 07 December 2016 12:55

Wanted: social licence to eradicate and keep out future pests

Written by  Pam Tipa
Sir Peter Gluckman. Sir Peter Gluckman.

Some form of genetic technologies will in 10, 20 or 30 years be our primary defence against the inevitable biosecurity incursions that will occur.

So says Sir Peter Gluckman, the Prime Minister’s chief science advisor.

“We will never be able to stop every incursion. The issue is how “will we get social licence for these new technologies?’ ” he asked the recent Biosecurity 2016 Forum in Auckland,

“That is the big issue for Australia, New Zealand and every society: as these new technologies develop, how will societies decide whether to use them or not?”

If the first use of the internet had been clearly by the World Trade Centre bombers and not for social media, the world would have reacted against that technology. If the first use of genetic modification had been by Government agencies to produce a food to reduce the incidence of diabetes in the world there would have been a different response.

“We need to get far better at having good discussions with society, not late in the development of a technology but at the beginning of the development of that technology so we can understand what society will allow to happen at what pace.”

He reminded the forum that margarine was only first allowed to be sold in NZ without a prescription in 1972.

By definition we always live in an experimental society, he says. Everything human beings do in social or technological innovation has a degree of risk and unknown.

“There is no such thing as proving absolutely safety; that is scientifically impossible. And therefore different perceptions of relative risk and relative precaution always remain.”

In addition to scientists’ analysis of risk, people also perceive risk at many levels – whether they will benefit, or not benefit.

“Who incurs the risk, who incurs the cost? A whole lot of biases and so forth. There is a third class of risk – political risk, institutional risk and reputational risk. So in risk management all these things come together.”

Better public conversations are needed. Social science and behavioural science need to come into it. For instance how to get people of different cultures to understand the significance of biosecurity to our heritage and economy.

“Is what we do on an aeroplane, i.e. making a rather bland announcement about biosecurity, actually the best way of persuading airline passengers to declare what they have in their bags?

“We need to research how we nudge people of different cultures, backgrounds and heritages to think about it. Biosecurity is ultimately a behavioural phenomenon to some extent.”

Gluckman says our primary industries are a set of large monocultures, be it pine trees, kiwifruit, ryegrass and clover, sheep or cows. The more monocultural your agricultural system, the more at risk it is.

A kiwifruit farmer had asked him what his greatest form of defence was. “Genetic diversity is your best defence against bugs of different kinds,” he says. “It was fortunate and almost an accident that Plant and Food had a number of cultivars present when the Psa epidemic broke out and they found out they had a resistant cultivar which turned out to be of great productivity value.”

Gluckman released a paper in late November on perceptions of risk in science.

More like this

Mealybug warnings

As mealybugs gain a foothold in Central Otago, grapegrowers are being urged to be vigilant for signs of Grapevine Leafroll-associated Virus Type 3 (leafroll 3) in vines.

Featured

 

Limited feed puts ewes at risk

Severe feed shortages in parts of the country mean many ewes are on a nutritional knife-edge heading into lambing and could be at risk of developing metabolic disorders.

Jack’s unique solution

Jason Jack was left with severe spinal injuries after a wakeboarding accident when he was 29, but that hasn’t stopped him getting out and about in difficult environments.

National

A ticking time bomb

Our dairy industry risks being exposed to a ‘ticking time bomb’ of unethical players unlawfully passing off New Zealand-made and…

Nervous wait for winter

The unknown of what winter will bring is very much on the mind of the Hawkes Bay Rural Support Trust…

Be careful, Potatoes NZ!

Moves by the NZ potato industry to have anti-dumping tariffs imposed on European imports could play into the hands of…

China keeps dairy prices high

Whole milk powder (WMP) prices are now sitting above pre-Covid-19 levels and New Zealand farmers can thank a resurging Chinese…

Machinery & Products

Hydrogen excavator a first

While most motive industries are focused on hybrid or EV power plants, JCB has developed the construction industry’s first hydrogen-powered…

Jack’s unique solution

Jason Jack was left with severe spinal injuries after a wakeboarding accident when he was 29, but that hasn’t stopped…

HP and digital tech combo

The latest New Holland T8 GENESIS is said to capitalise on the productive combinations of Stage V horsepower and digital…